governance alive 2019

qmail (via netqmail) notqmail

notqmail is a community-driven fork of qmail, which had not been officially updated since 1998. It consolidates decades of scattered patches into a maintained, unified successor to both qmail and netqmail.

What it is

notqmail is based on netqmail (which was based on qmail 1.03) with accumulated community patches integrated. It maintains qmail's security-focused architecture of separate, minimally-privileged programs communicating through well-defined interfaces. Hosted on GitHub with a collaborative development model.

The story

qmail was created by Daniel J. Bernstein starting in December 1995 as a secure alternative to Sendmail. The last official release, qmail 1.03, came in 1998, after which Bernstein essentially abandoned active development while prohibiting modified distributions due to his license terms. For years, qmail users relied on collections of third-party patches to add features like SMTP AUTH, TLS, and large message support.

In 2007, when Bernstein placed qmail 1.03 in the public domain, the netqmail project consolidated the most important patches into a single meta-distribution. However, netqmail itself became abandoned after its last release on November 30, 2007.

In 2019, Amitai Schleier, a NetBSD contributor and longtime qmail administrator, founded the notqmail project to finally provide a properly maintained, community-driven successor. notqmail begins where netqmail left off, providing stable, compatible releases that integrate accumulated patches while maintaining backward compatibility with existing qmail configurations. The project explicitly aims to be a collaborative open-source project rather than a single-maintainer effort.

Timeline

Dan Bernstein begins developing qmail

qmail 1.03 released (last official version)

qmail placed in public domain; netqmail released

notqmail project founded by Amitai Schleier

notqmail 1.08 released

Key people

Daniel J. Bernstein
Original qmail creator
Amitai Schleier
notqmail founder and maintainer

Impact

notqmail represents a rare case of a fork emerging over two decades after the original's last release. It demonstrates that important infrastructure software can accumulate a long tail of unofficial patches that eventually need consolidation into a maintained project. The fork addresses the governance vacuum left by a single-maintainer project whose author moved on.

Lesson: Single-maintainer projects with restrictive licenses create long-term governance problems. qmail's two-decade gap between official releases shows that even technically excellent software needs ongoing maintenance. notqmail demonstrates that it is never too late to fork and consolidate community efforts, though building momentum after such a long gap is challenging.